id pick one up if i didnt already have the new gasket here for mine already. I've used quite a few 'rtv-less' gaskets..those steel reinforced ones are the best! I run them on the valve covers and trans pan of my 'cuda with no issues. It LOOKS like the right kind.
Also note, the ones i have on my 'Cuda are steel reinforced and have some rubber like coating on them. 110% reuseable.. I'd bet those probably are too. If they dont crush, and dont stick to either surface...its worth a shot
And if you are pulling your third member every weekend, why not just get a suction pump? I've done that before as well and got a very good portion of the fluid out and didn't have to deal with the gasket
JK Rubicon, 2dr - 37s, beadlocks, ram assist, cage, 12klb winch, etc, etc