Link above and posted above is exactly what you want. Black.
I believe the 99 and older, possibly it was 97 and older had metal tailgate and door handles. They are the plastic "styled" ones like we have. When my brother was rear ended, the body shop got a tailgate from an older truck, and didn't replace the handle. And we noticed it. Made them put the correct handle on it.
I'll see if i can dig up a pic.