IMO it really comes down to how you use the tire. Are you just wanting a look? Or go off roading?
I'm a street guy myself. (about the only one here at R-F w/a 4x4 too LOL)
When I upgrade I'll probably go with some 15" wheels & 32" tires. Then just live with what ever reduced turn radius & articulation I need to. Shoot.. the only reason I have 4x4 is because of Michigan winters. Gotta admit I do like the look though.