the cigarette lighter socket (the one closest to the steering wheel) seems to be a common thing to break on these trucks. You most likely broke the lip that held it in, what i did to fix it was get some epoxy and put it around the lighter socket behind the bezel. I now have removed that and build a level control for my sub amp in its place.
Here is a pic of it. If you have a sub then this would be a cool mod to do.