Supercharger for towing?
Thinking about the rpcaster kit for my 02 fx4 manual?
I basically want it for power, but wonder about how it would work for towing, too much stress? |
well the truck still has the same gross weight so you didnt add towing capacity yes you will have more HP but yes more stress on the already not strong R1 trans
|
i've never found a good reference on how a supercharger hurts long term life on an engine... all i've seen is that it needed its own oil changed about every 6 months
i doubt towing with a sc would hurt it tho. i've seen people pulling with Harley trucks |
Originally Posted by Redneckstone
(Post 1536567)
well the truck still has the same gross weight so you didnt add towing capacity yes you will have more HP but yes more stress on the already not strong R1 trans
|
if you keep boost normal and not underdrive pulley it the motor will be fine. its the R1 i still think would be the problem child
|
Originally Posted by Noone
(Post 1537284)
i doubt towing with a sc would hurt it tho. i've seen people pulling with Harley trucks
|
Originally Posted by Roach2004
(Post 1537315)
Your also talking about a 5.4L V8 that has alot more towing power to begin with. That is not an accurate comparison.
|
we've got a crappy ass manual trans....it go kaboom in stock output form(I would know)....i'd hate to see it with a screw ontop of it, much less towing quite a bit.
Simply doesn't have the structural integrity to do the S/C and in turn handle abuse , and simply doesn't have the right gear and is missing reliable hydraulic clutch system to support the towing of anything heavier than like 3500. |
WHY OR WHAT MAKES THESE MANUALS SUCH SH!TTY TRANS???
|
Well my boat only weighs about 3000lbs TOPS on the trailer. So its not too bad, I just wanted a little more power. Zach mocked me for having a stick the first time i met him, hahaha.
Maybe i should throw the asp udp on my truck, I just want a little more jam for towing, once its going its fine, but its the up to speed part, and sometimes the maintaining speed part at low rpms thats bugging me. But I've had my fire chief (also a mechanic) drive the setup, and he says its fine and I'm just being too picky. Chris |
Originally Posted by TOPH R
(Post 1537756)
Well my boat only weighs about 3000lbs TOPS on the trailer. So its not too bad, I just wanted a little more power. Zach mocked me for having a stick the first time i met him, hahaha.
Maybe i should throw the asp udp on my truck, I just want a little more jam for towing, once its going its fine, but its the up to speed part, and sometimes the maintaining speed part at low rpms thats bugging me. But I've had my fire chief (also a mechanic) drive the setup, and he says its fine and I'm just being too picky. Chris by Zach do you mean me? why in hell would i mock someone for a manual? most the vehicles i have driven daily are manauls up till this black truck. which still might become a manual in time here |
Originally Posted by Fx4wannabe01
(Post 1537368)
we've got a crappy ass manual trans....
|
^^^ yes but i was towing between 4-5k with my truck almost ever weekend over the winter and my trans held up. but mine only has 30k in it since it was rebuilt
|
Originally Posted by GrafixGuy
(Post 1537782)
you mean the auto trans is stronger?
they love to blow reverse seals tho, mine has to have a rip on the oring or something it shutters in reverse |
re: roach
Originally Posted by Roach2004
(Post 1537315)
Your also talking about a 5.4L V8 that has alot more towing power to begin with. That is not an accurate comparison.
i know its a different engine, I'm talking about if a supercharged engine, or a supercharger itself, can handle the additional stress loads created by an towing. i really don't know anything about them. i don't think many people who install a supercharger run it for 100k+ miles like most of us want out of our trucks. |
Well, I don't know what you're pulling but my Ranger seems to pull everything just fine. I have even pulled a 1200 pound trailer with a Chevy 1500 on it and my truck squatted like a MOFO but the truck sure pulled great.
I'm fairly certain the Supercharger can handle the stress of the trailer. Its really not that big of a deal since it spools down to 1/2hp draw when you're not acclerating. |
speaking from exp. buy an older f150 for towing, ive gone through 4 almost 5 automatics just from yanking pulling.
i dont like manual trans for towing unless its a bigger truck. like zach said these trans heat up way to fast, the factory trans cooler likes to blow the lines off, reverse and overdrive bands break way to easy. Hell my current trans doesnt like to shift unless i play with the shifter and even when crusing itll pop into neutral. Another thing these frames arent that thick, they twist very easily, if i have to post pics of what i recently did yanking a car through a 6ft pile of snow i will. save your self the hassle, buy an older f150 with a v8 and either auto or stick..itll do the job. |
i want to see them
|
yea yea, its a twisted frame, that and the trans really doesnt like me. time to buy another trans ha.
|
All times are GMT -6. The time now is 03:30 AM. |
© 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands