4.0 or 2.3?
 

i bought a 2007 fx4 off road ranger which only has 5400 miles since new. loaded up and ordered. i dont drive it much as i want because of gas. i was thinking of selling it and buying a 08 or 09 single cab 2.3 manual ranger. am i nuts to do this?. i like the 4.0 power even though my brother-in-laws tocoma will smoke me. he took me for a ride in his 05 trd sport. pretty nice truck. has lots of power. whats the highest price i could get for my 07 off road?.

your nuts PERIOD. to be quite honest, i really wish i could get the gas mileage yall are getting. if i can afford im gunna trade my fullsize in for a 4.0 ranger.

19-20k probably

i wouldnt do it if it was me. this is what makes no sense from your thread...

1. new ranger with 5400 (not even broke in)
2. dont drive if for gas reasons
3. tacoma will smoke your ranger (yet worried about gas prices)
4. you want a 2.3l but dont like the fact that a toy beat you
5. i would imagine you owe more than you will get out of your ranger but i could be wrong.

so wth that stated id keep the 4.0 it will break in more and you should see 17-18mpg as a normal driver

^^^ exactly what zach said.

yea i hear ya. its not my daily driver but i do drive a least once a week. i not even sure that that tocoma would smoke me that bad. 4.0s go pretty good. i saw a nice level2 on the bay a 07 black with 9200 miles. thing was sweet. anybody see it?.

With the cost of gas I personally don't give a hoot if grandma Moses passes me. That is why I pull 24+mpg out of my 4.0 w/182.xxxmi on it.
When I need the power I have plenty and sometimes use it. My truck can and has pulled it's own weight and more. If my truck was just used around town I would want the 2.3L but mine is used in all kind of conditions. My X-cab and 4x4 are a nice thing to have in the winter conditions I have to deal with.
BTW, the 24mpg is not a typo, I'm a hypermiler.

He hyper miles and gets 24mpg. I drive like a bat out of Hades and get 28mpg. I'm sure I get where I'm going faster even though I get better millage. The 2.3 is the way to go if you worry about millage. personally it's not my biggest concern, which is why I drive like I do. I could prolly do better than 30mpg if I slowed down abit.
How 'bout this, I'll trade you motors, 'cause I'd love to have the 4.0!

you could always buy an older ranger with a 4banger to use as a daily .... cause i heard they dont offer the 4cyl with an xcab anymore.

I'm willing to bet you would be lucky to break even on your truck right now.... I wouldn't bother... you're going to spend more money, have more hassle, and may end up more unhappy then you are now. Keep what you have or get a car.... you already have a great truck!

thanks. i think im keeping the ranger for now. it is nice and i love ford trucks. ill use my old 88 mazda b2200 for my daily 4 banger 5 speed. i was going to sell both trucks and just get a 08 2.3 single cab 5 speed but down the road ill see. thanks.