Replacement Engine vs. Totaling it Out
#1
Replacement Engine vs. Totaling it Out
I am curious to see if there is anyone here that has had experience or has any good information regarding insurance claims.
I have owned a 2000 Ford Ranger (manual 5spd) for the last 5 years. It currently has ~78,000 miles on it. About 2 weeks ago, we had significant rain in our area. Our power went out and our basement started to flood. I took off just before this to pick up a generator and in the process, entered water that was about 3 feet deep. It was 1am when this all went down, so obviously it was impossible to tell how deep the water was. Also, I was focused on getting this generator home to save our basement and belongings.
Water entered the intake through the filter and killed the truck. Long story short, I got the truck started, but bent a rod and blew a head. I had the truck towed to a local Ford dealership thinking they would be the experts in engine replacement in a Ford vehicle. This dealership is an Authorized Repair Facility for my insurance company, so no adjuster is required to be present for the dealer to submit a quote/work order and get the work authorized.
Keep in mind that my truck books at about 2,000-2,500 tops. The dealer is anxious to replace the engine and get the truck back to me. I'm okay with it in theory because the truck is paid off with low miles. However, I have a problem with them picking engines out of junk yards with similar mileage. They replaced the first engine on Friday with 39,000 miles on it and it seized up right away on them.
I told them to not touch the truck until an adjuster could come out Monday to take a look at the vehicle and their quote to see what he thought. Am I wrong for thinking that the dealer just wants the maintenance work instead of totaling the vehicle out? The problem I have is that this "new" engine could last 6 months, a year, whatever. The insurance company said I would be covered in the future, but how far and how much are they going to fight it the further we get away from the claim? Also, there is no way the vehicle will be worth it's previous value once an engine has been replaced. I won't lie to a buyer, and I know I'd run away from a vehicle that has had an engine replacement if I were looking for a dependable vehicle.
The adjuster should be out Monday to take a look. Am I wrong for not wanting this truck back? If the truck was worth 5,000-10,000 I could understand, but replacing the engine in a $2,500 vehicle? Sounds like throwing good money after bad.
Any opinions on this? Thanks!
I have owned a 2000 Ford Ranger (manual 5spd) for the last 5 years. It currently has ~78,000 miles on it. About 2 weeks ago, we had significant rain in our area. Our power went out and our basement started to flood. I took off just before this to pick up a generator and in the process, entered water that was about 3 feet deep. It was 1am when this all went down, so obviously it was impossible to tell how deep the water was. Also, I was focused on getting this generator home to save our basement and belongings.
Water entered the intake through the filter and killed the truck. Long story short, I got the truck started, but bent a rod and blew a head. I had the truck towed to a local Ford dealership thinking they would be the experts in engine replacement in a Ford vehicle. This dealership is an Authorized Repair Facility for my insurance company, so no adjuster is required to be present for the dealer to submit a quote/work order and get the work authorized.
Keep in mind that my truck books at about 2,000-2,500 tops. The dealer is anxious to replace the engine and get the truck back to me. I'm okay with it in theory because the truck is paid off with low miles. However, I have a problem with them picking engines out of junk yards with similar mileage. They replaced the first engine on Friday with 39,000 miles on it and it seized up right away on them.
I told them to not touch the truck until an adjuster could come out Monday to take a look at the vehicle and their quote to see what he thought. Am I wrong for thinking that the dealer just wants the maintenance work instead of totaling the vehicle out? The problem I have is that this "new" engine could last 6 months, a year, whatever. The insurance company said I would be covered in the future, but how far and how much are they going to fight it the further we get away from the claim? Also, there is no way the vehicle will be worth it's previous value once an engine has been replaced. I won't lie to a buyer, and I know I'd run away from a vehicle that has had an engine replacement if I were looking for a dependable vehicle.
The adjuster should be out Monday to take a look. Am I wrong for not wanting this truck back? If the truck was worth 5,000-10,000 I could understand, but replacing the engine in a $2,500 vehicle? Sounds like throwing good money after bad.
Any opinions on this? Thanks!
#3
Thanks for the reply.
The bad part is, I would really not like to have a loan payment again, at least for a while. Even more, I don't want a vehicle that is not dependable. I am anxious to see what the adjuster says. I have a hard time believing that it is a cut and dried answer to throw pulled engines into this truck and ship it out.
I guess tomorrow I'll know for sure.
The bad part is, I would really not like to have a loan payment again, at least for a while. Even more, I don't want a vehicle that is not dependable. I am anxious to see what the adjuster says. I have a hard time believing that it is a cut and dried answer to throw pulled engines into this truck and ship it out.
I guess tomorrow I'll know for sure.
#4
Did you drive it after you got it started or did it just go "kerplunk"? Remember, both axles, transmission, and interior also went for that same swim. You could put anywhere from 50 bucks to 3 grand into this after the motor is done. I.E. both axles need the fluid changed, I would change fluid and filter in tranny also, and don't forget about the interior.
Just some things to think about...
Just some things to think about...
#5
#7
Did you drive it after you got it started or did it just go "kerplunk"? Remember, both axles, transmission, and interior also went for that same swim. You could put anywhere from 50 bucks to 3 grand into this after the motor is done. I.E. both axles need the fluid changed, I would change fluid and filter in tranny also, and don't forget about the interior.
Just some things to think about...
Just some things to think about...
#8
#9
Thanks for the reply, guys. The adjuster seconded the notion to fix the vehicle. I found out today that they plan on stripping out the interior, which I don't care nearly as much about. I was told after they got an engine into it that the ABS light came on, which I have been having problems with, but fixed by changing out the fluid two weeks before this incident.
I'm kind of leaning towards trading the vehicle in, as much as I hate dealing with dealers. I just don't need the headaches down the road, and I will worry about it constantly, problems or not.
I'm kind of leaning towards trading the vehicle in, as much as I hate dealing with dealers. I just don't need the headaches down the road, and I will worry about it constantly, problems or not.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
auto.guru
General Ford Ranger Discussion
0
07-15-2014 04:46 PM
dane5547
General Ford Ranger Discussion
0
06-06-2008 08:52 AM
dane5547
SOHC - 2.3L & 2.5L Lima Engines
0
06-06-2008 08:18 AM