I can't decide what tire I want to go with, if you guys could pick one of these two what would you go with and why.

Nitto Terra Grappler



Mickey Thompson ATZ



Ignore the DCs

 

id do the mickey thompson atz bc they do better in the sand then any of the other too. and your on the road and in more sand than anything else

 

None.

I vote dune grapplers!!

 

Yeah I've heard they do great in the sand too. I really like the sidewall on them as well, it looks more aggressive than the others.

Ok the DCs are out, way to expensive.

 

Yuck, I think those are ugly.

 

Out of those too I would have to go with the Nitto Terra Grappler's

 

ATZ's. The sidewalls look a little more protected for some light offroad use. The Terra Grapplers look like they would pop if you kissed a curb or something. Though the grapplers are probably more smooth and quiet with smaller tread blocks.

 

id go the nittos. I love my set.

 

I'm really leaning towards the Nittos being there cheaper. It will probably come down to which one I like better in person.

 

I have had both, the ATZ's will end up sucking when driving in the rain over time and they suck in any kind of mud, but for everyday street driving they are good, not loud at all. The nitto's are good, great on the street and in the rain...mud, its ok...nothing special, about the same as a BFG AT.

The ATZ's are hands down the better looking tire when mounted though, the nitto's are deceptive when looking at them on-line, I think they look a lot better when mounted on a wide wheel...on a normal width wheel (factory wheel) they look like a factory tire.

Not sure about sand for the both of them, no sand around here.

 

go to offroaders.com and look at reviews

i know a girl with the atz tires on her dodge and the seem to wear great and ride great with out noise. i couldnt tell you anything about how they do offroad.

 

Ive always been partial to the ATZ's, Ive heard great things about them

 

they are both just cool lookin street tires. neither are really offroad tires

 

I never said I was looking for offroad tires. I want a good riding street tire with semi aggressive looks that is good in sand and still decent offroad.

 

I voted for the Terra Grappler, I've always like the looks of them and have only heard good things about them. The ATZ's just look ugly in my eyes and the sipes are really close together so I can see why they would suck in the rain.

 

You guys aren't helping at all, the vote is 50/50 lol

 

What about Toyo O/C A/T's? They are similar to the Nittos but I hear they have a harder compound so they last a little longer. Otherwise I say The Nittos.

 

No option for neither? Sorry..

 

NiTTO

 

Id go with the ATZ's. THey look a little more aggressive IMO. I also like mickey thompson.

 

I would recommend not going with the Terra Grappler. Absolutely terrible tire. I've had them on my work truck now for around 3000km. The truck is a 1 ton, flat deck with a lot of weight in the back (dont know how much but it needed 3 extra leafs per side to sit back at stock). Decent tire for pavement wet or dry and dry dirt/gravel, but in anything snotty, muddy, icy or snow my truck became a completely frustrating chore to drive. 4wd and keeping her pointed straight with the throttle not going over 40km/hr is an absolute blast...not.

The crappy stock chevy tires were waay better, especially in snow and ice.

Just my experience.

 

My dads 150 has like 50something thousand miles on his Terra Grapps, I like them and would recommend them. Actually was going get them to for the Ranger but they are lame and stopped making 15" wheel tires. But at the same time I also really love the ATZ's, as far as looks go the ATZ's are hands down the winner. I think I'd just get whatever you could get for cheapest if theres a big price gap.

 

Yeah it will probably come down to price. Knowing my luck both will be close to the same lol

 

Neither. I vote the Michelin LTX M/S. Or the X-Radial. They are the same tire.

 

Gross, those are ugly too