Is there a certain company that you guys would suggest for a replacement carpet? I want to switch from gray to black carpet and don't want to end up getting a poor quality carpet.

 

I have gotten parts from LMC Truck over the years, all were good quality but never got carpet from them.

Look here for LMC Ranger carpets: Truck Parts and Truck Accessories

And there are alot of sellers of Ranger carpets on ebay, but can't say one would be better than another

 

Try to check out the online store of Stock Interiors they are selling replacement carpets for Ford Ranger.